c++ - What do linkers actually do with multiply-defined `inline` functions?

Question

In both C and C++, inline functions with external linkage can of course have multiple definitions available at link-time, the assumption being that these definitions are all (hopefully) identical. (I am of course referring to functions declared with the inline linkage specification, not to functions that the compiler or link-time-optimizer actually inlines.)

So what do common linkers typically do when they encounter multiple definitions of a function? In particular:

• Are all definitions included in the final executable or shared-library?
• Do all invocations of the function link against the same definition?
• Are the answers to the above questions required by one or more of the C and C++ ISO standards, and if not, do most common platforms do the same thing?

P.S. Yes, I know C and C++ are separate languages, but they both support inline, and their compiler-output can typically be linked by the same linker (e.g. GCC's ld), so I believe there cannot be any difference between them in this aspect.

Answer 1

If the function is, in fact, inlined, then there's nothing to link. It's only when, for whatever reason, the compiler decides not to expand the function inline that it has to generate an out-of-line version of the function. If the compiler generates an out-of-line version of the function for more than one translation unit you end up with more than one object file having definitions for the same "inline" function.

The out-of-line definition gets compiled into the object file, and it's marked so that the linker won't complain if there is more than one definition of that name. If there is more than one, the linker simply picks one. Usually the first one it saw, but that's not required, and if the definitions are all the same, it doesn't matter. And that's why it's undefined behavior to have two or more different definitions of the same inline function: there's no rule for which one to pick. Anything can happen.