c# - ASP.NET Custom Controls - Composites

Question

Summary

Hi All,
OK, further into my adventures with custom controls...

In summary, here is that I have learned of three main "classes" of custom controls. Please feel free to correct me if any of this is wrong!

1. UserControls - Which inherit from UserControl and are contained within an ASCX file. These are pretty limited in what they can do, but are a quick and light way to get some UI commonality with designer support.
2. Custom Composite Controls - These are controls that inherit from WebControl where you add pre-existing controls to the control within the CreateChildControls method. This provides great flexibility, but lack of designer support without additional coding. They are highly portable though since they can be compiled into a DLL.
3. Custom Rendered Controls - Similar to Custom Composite Controls, these are added to a Web Control Library project. The rendering of the control is completely controlled by the programmer by overriding the Render method.

My Thoughts..

OK, so while playing with custom composites, I found the following:

• You have little/no control over the HTML output making it difficult to "debug".
• The CreateChildControls (and subsequent methods) can get real busy with Controls.Add(myControl) everywhere.
• I found rendering tables (be it for layout or content) to be considerably awkward.

The Question(s)..

So, I admit, I am new to this so I could be way off-base with some of my points noted above..

• Do you use Composites?
• Do you have any neat tricks to control the HTML output?
• Do you just say "to hell with it" and go ahead and create a custom rendered control?

Its something I am keen to get really firm in my mind since I know how much good control development can cut overall development time.

I look forward to your answers ^_^

Answer 1

I say go ahead with the custom rendered control. I find that in most cases the composite can be easier done and used in a UserControl, but anything beyond that and you'd need to have a finer degree of control (pun unintended) to merit your own rendering strategy.

There maybe controls that are simple enough to merit a composite (e.g., a textbox combined with a javascript/dhtml based datepicker, for example) but beyond that one example, it looks like custom rendered controls are the way to go.