php - Which is better: mysql_connect or mysql_pconnect

Question

I'm a PHP newbie working a some scripts to display some news articles from a databse and wanted to find out a couple of things.

• For opening a connection to a MySQL database, which is a better option mysql_connect or mysql_pconnect?
• What are the advantages or drawbacks of using a persistent connection to the database?
• And in what kind of scenario will a persistent connection be called for?

Answer 1

If you are going to write a web page there is no need of persistent connection. It takes too much resources. Use mysql_connect. Minimize the time your db connection is open and not used as much as you can. Open, fetch what you want, close. It doesn't need to stay open while the users are just reading. The connection will be used eventually if they respond - INSERT/go to another page..

Here are some good points about NOT USING persistent connection in web applications

• When you lock a table, normally it is unlocked when the connection closes, but since persistent connections do not close, any tables you accidentally leave locked will remain locked, and the only way to unlock them is to wait for the connection to timeout or kill the process. The same locking problem occurs with transactions. (See comments below on 23-Apr-2002 & 12-Jul-2003)

• Normally temporary tables are dropped when the connection closes, but since persistent connections do not close, temporary tables aren't so temporary. If you do not explicitly drop temporary tables when you are done, that table will already exist for a new client reusing the same connection. The same problem occurs with setting session variables. (See comments below on 19-Nov-2004 & 07-Aug-2006)

• If PHP and MySQL are on the same server or local network, the connection time may be negligible, in which case there is no advantage to persistent connections.

• Apache does not work well with persistent connections. When it receives a request from a new client, instead of using one of the available children which already has a persistent connection open, it tends to spawn a new child, which must then open a new database connection. This causes excess processes which are just sleeping, wasting resources, and causing errors when you reach your maximum connections, plus it defeats any benefit of persistent connections. (See comments below on 03-Feb-2004, and the footnote at http://devzone.zend.com/node/view/id/686#fn1)